News Stories

Got a tip or story? Share it with MAGNIFYI®.


Staff Recommends Preserving Current Cost Allocation Methodology For Ancillary Services

Dockets: 58555 ,Texas

October 29, 2026 PUCT Staff issue its recommended findings and next steps  regarding ERCOT’s ancillary and reliability services cost allocation study pursuant to PURA §39.1593. (See Attachment B of the Staff’s recommended findings for ERCOT’s Report on Ancillary and Reliability Services Cost Allocation Study.)

As background, by December 1, 2026, the Commission must evaluate and report to the Legislature on aspects of the cost allocation of ancillary and reliability services in the ERCOT power region.  In response Commission Staff collaborated with ERCOT, stakeholders, and the Independent Market Monitor to devise the evaluation. The assessment analyzed historical data and considered the need for ancillary and reliability service deployment. The evaluation compared the current cost allocation methodology with alternatives to determine whether a change would result in consumer savings.

Specifically, the study evaluated the following cost allocation methods:

Base Case: Current load-ratio-share allocation – Defined in the ERCOT Protocols. AS and RS costs are allocated to Qualified Scheduling Entities (QSEs) representing load every 15 minutes or hourly, depending on the service, and settled daily. Allocation ratios are based on each QSE’s load ratio share.3 No AS and RS costs are currently allocated to any generation resources.

Alternative Method A: High-risk-hour load and generation allocation – Described in PURA § 39.1593(b)(1). AS costs are allocated and settled semiannually among dispatchable resources, non-dispatchable resources, and load based on the contribution of each group to unreliability during times of highest reliability risk.

Alternative Method B: All hour operational risk-based allocation – Like Method A, but all hours are used to calculate allocation ratios, and settlement is daily. AS costs are allocated hourly and settled daily among dispatchable resources, non-dispatchable resources, and load. As in Method A AS costs are allocated using ratios for each group that reflect that group’s contribution to the operational risk(s) and causes for deployment each AS addresses. Unlike Method A, allocation ratios for Method B are calculated based on all hours in a year, rather than only high reliability risk hours. RS costs are allocated using the same approach as in Method A.

Alternative Method C: QSE capacity-short allocation – Hourly allocation and daily settlement. AS and RS costs are allocated hourly and settled daily to QSEs representing load, which enter the market short of scheduled generation relative to their scheduled load. To calculate appropriate allocation ratios for this method, the analysis adapts the capacity-short framework for allocating Reliability Unit Commitment make-whole costs. Costs are first assigned to QSEs that enter real time or the day-ahead market short of generation relative to their load, subject to a cap. Any remaining cost is allocated based on load ratio share.

Following the evaluation Staff concluded that “the current cost allocation methodology should be preserved. None of the alternative allocation methodologies examined are expected to yield any net consumer savings.”

Staff seeks feedback on its recommended findings and next steps.

Key Study Findings

Finding 1: Alternative Methods Yield No Net Consumer Savings – “While, in the short term, each alternative method reallocates costs amongst load, dispatchable generation, and non-dispatchable generation differently at the wholesale level, ERCOT’s analysis of expected market behavior in response to this reallocation shows that none of the three alternative methods is expected to deliver net savings for consumers in the long term. As ERCOT’s report concluded reallocation by itself does not lower the quantity of AS and RS procured or reduce prices.”

“Using data from 2024-2025, Method A would shift approximately $617 million, or 60.8% of total wholesale AS and RS costs from load to generation, while Method B would shift approximately $593 million, or 58.4% of total costs from load to generation. Staff agrees with ERCOT’s analysis, which found that these costs would function primarily as fixed costs for generators, and therefore these costs would not be expected to impact generators’ short-term offer or scheduling behavior. This may imply thatthere could be some short-term savings for consumers due to some portion of costs being shifted to generators. However, the analysis also found that total system costs are expected to be higher due to implementation, settlement, and credit impacts. Additionally, the newly imposed AS costs on generators are expected to eventually be passed on to consumers through higher prices and offers for energy, AS, and RS. These higher prices and offers are expected due to market shifts such as accelerated retirements or delayed market entries that could result from higher generator costs.”

“ERCOT’s analysis showed that Method C strengthens incentives for QSEs to manage capacity-short positions through bilateral trading and contracting. However, because the ERCOT system was capacity short in only approximately 0.3% of settlement intervals during 2024-2025, the analysis showed roughly 96% of AS and RS costs would ultimately continue to be allocated through Load Ratio Share. As a result, Method C largely changes who bears costs during relatively rare scarcity conditions rather than reducing overall system costs. The increased incentive for market participants to avoid capacity-short positions in real-time, under this methodology, is small and therefore would be unlikely to result in significant short-term behavior changes.”

Finding 2: All Three Alternative Methods Introduce Costs or Risks – “Method A would introduce significant settlement, collateral, and credit impacts by replacing daily settlements with semiannual settlements. Methods B and C would preserve daily settlement but would still require significant settlement changes.

All three alternative methods would require process and systems changes for both ERCOT and market participants. The study found no evidence that these implementation costs and risks would be offset by consumer savings.

Next Steps

 Commission will continue to promote efficient AS and RS procurement – “Updates to ERCOT’s AS Methodology require Commission approval, providing a recurring opportunity for the Commission to oversee this process. As a result, the Commission will continue to monitor whether AS design and procurement remains consistent with cost-causation principles and adheres with nondiscrimination requirements found in PURA § 35.004(h).”

Commission will continue to engage in Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service design and implementation – “ERCOT has begun implementation of NPRR1309, Board Priority – Dispatchable Reliability Reserve Service (DRRS) Ancillary Service, and its project management office estimated during an October 2026 meeting of the Protocol Revision Subcommittee that implementation will be complete in mid2028. The Commission will continue to actively participate in the implementation of the new DRRS service, including ensuring that its design and procurement are consistent with cost-causation principles and on a nondiscriminatory basis, as required by PURA § 35.004(h).

Based on implementation timing, DRRS must also be considered in ERCOT’s 2028 AS Methodology development so that quantities may be determined. As for the other AS, the quantities will be determined based on statistical or probabilistic analysis of historical and expected future operational risks and system conditions. Commission staff will participate in this process, which will occur throughout most of 2027.”