Feature Articles
Have a topic request or want to submit an article? Contact the MAGNIFYI Editors
Election Results Highlight Pushback Against Data Centers
Data centers face mounting requirements in the states with retail energy choice, as new governors-elect pledge moratoria in Texas and Ohio, and governors who have already issued tough executive orders were re-elected in Maryland, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, New York and Illinois.
Developers will face a gauntlet of state agencies to get their projects approved in these states, as well as in New Jersey and Virginia.
Hard-line positions on data centers were campaign issues of governors-elect in states without retail power, such as Georgia, Nevada and Iowa.
All of these governors are Democrats. The hurdles created by them and some Republican predecessors now constitute a long checklist of must-haves that could steer data construction to one location instead of another.
While each state has adopted a unique approach, typical requirements include air and water protection, a new power rate class, use of clean electricity, the elimination of non-disclosure agreements, mandatory approval or consultation by local government agencies and early curtailment during power shortages.
“The competitive advantage may ultimately belong to the state that makes large-load investment decisions predictable, not necessarily the state that makes approvals easiest,” said Neil Osnato, founder of consultant Persistence Analytics Group.
“The most interesting question is whether the actions of the governors are creating a coherent system of investment certainty, or a fragmented collection of obligations that neither developers nor infrastructure providers can reliably price,” he added. “That distinction could determine whether regulation becomes a competitive advantage or a competitive liability.”
Regulations that add predictable costs are tolerable, while those that add long, opaque timelines are fatal, said Pavankumar Kamat, CEO at Panto AI, an artificial intelligence testing company.
The real economic deterrent is an unpredictable price or an enforcement regime that can change mid-build, he said, that forces investors to apply a large risk premium or walk.
Data Centers Are Scrutinized in Texas
Democratic victories in state elections, particularly in Texas, could lead to tighter data center restrictions and project delays, according to investment bank Morgan Stanley, “although the broader artificial intelligence investment cycle is expected to stay the same.”
The states where Democrats are likely to further restrict data center development account for roughly 45% of planned US data center capacity, with Texas alone accounting for roughly 25%, investment bank Goldman Sachs said.
Analysts at the firm this month forecasted U.S. data center construction spending of $80 billion this year, $100 billion in 2027 and $125 billion in 2028.
Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa pledged to pause new data center permits and construction until lawmakers can pass new regulations.
She campaigned on concerns over the amounts of water and electricity consumed by the facilities, warning that localities face a risk of shortages and rising energy costs.
She also campaigned against long-term tax breaks and exemptions for the industry. Her predecessor whom she defeated, Republican Greg Abbott, signed a bill in 2015 to give data centers 20-year tax breaks.
Abbott appeared to heed constituent concerns this year and directed state regulators to pause new data center connections until a review of all projects in the queue of the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) could be completed.
One data center developer in west Texas told Magnifyi that the state is already suffering with the temporary halt, and that Hinojosa’s proposed moratorium has created uncertainty that shakes investor confidence.
“The need for power is so aggressive that things change on a weekly basis,” said Jose Ortega, principal in FO Permian, and Texas is already losing deals to other states and countries.
“If you have a question mark on permitting, it is a negating factor,” he said. “When you have a question mark in the diligence process, banks and investors will go where they can transact.”
FO Permian is developing a data center in Reeves County, and Ortega said conditions in Ector and Pecos counties favor the industry. Those counties are in the West Zone of ERCOT.
Ortega said he supports Hinojosa’s defense of constituents on issues of affordability and the predatory practices of data centers in other parts of the state.
The west Texas market is different, he added, and a blanket moratorium should not be applied for several reasons. Data center projects in the region have local support, he said, and the industry will produce economic benefits for rural communities in the short- and long-term.
“We also are using oversupplied, associated natural gas for power,” Ortega said, “and brackish, industrial and non-potable water.”
Associated gas is produced along with crude oil in the region and is usually sold at a price far less than the national benchmark, or even sold at a loss simply to transport it.
Ohio Joins of Growing Trend
Morgan Stanley said Ohio’s election of Amy Acton as governor “creates significant risk of data center project delays in the state.”
She campaigned on what she called a conditional moratorium, meaning that new data centers must meet several requirements. These include the use of carbon-free energy, construction only in brownfields locations, and the use of union labor, among others.
Another campaign pledge was that developers pay for all of their own electricity, gas, water, and infrastructure improvement costs. The projects “are also encouraged to bring self-sourced energy.”
The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio has put in place special data center rates for the state’s largest utilities, and has proposed them in another case.
New rate classes and clean-energy mandates increase operating costs and capital needs, but they are survivable if the rules are transparent and contractable, Kamat said.
Bring-your-own-power and non-rate protections shift technical and financial complexity to customers and suppliers, he added, and favor vertically integrated players or those with deep energy finance capability.
A clean energy procurement commitment and an operationally dependable energy resource are not necessarily equivalent, Osnato said.
“The issue is whether the represented energy supply is actually deliverable, appropriately matched to the customer’s operating requirements, and durable over the period in which the infrastructure investment is expected to be recovered,” he said.
Long Checklists in PJM States
The requirements in the executive orders of governors Josh Shapiro in Pennsylvania and Wes Moore in Maryland may prove challenging for the industry.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environment Protection will evaluate data centers when local communities approve them and developers line up their own clean power, cover related infrastructure costs, get their air and water permits and meet environmental justice standards.
Maryland will set up an executive-level task force to determine if a data center proposal sticks to a “coordinated review pathway” of the energy plans by developers. The state is looking to root out speculative and duplicate proposals and avoid stranded costs, among other project characteristics to be evaluated.
“Maryland and Pennsylvania illustrate the worst case,” Kamat said, “with multiple agency sign-offs and local veto points possibly creating delays for many calendar quarters or years.
“Time-to-market and certainty on approvals matter as much as any dollar per megawatt hour number,” he said.
Each extra approval in those two states will add time, and time is the cost that kills projects, said Steve Williams, an independent supply chain advisor who spent 25 years at Applied Materials in semiconductor capital equipment operations. The chips inside a data center go out of date fast, he said, so a site that is two years late is worth much less.
“Pennsylvania’s local-approval-first order puts the community consent risk at the front of the process,” Williams added. “That can be easier for a developer than finding out late.”
Osnato said Maryland and Pennsylvania illustrate the importance of coordination among utilities, regulators, environmental agencies, local governments, and economic development authorities.
These entities will evaluate different aspects of the same project, which becomes consequential when one approval relies on a representation that another agency subsequently modifies, rejects, or conditions.
“Multi-agency approvals can create uncertainty without necessarily creating bad policy,” Osnato said.
Editor’s Picks

