News Stories

Got a tip or story? Share it with MAGNIFYI®.


PSC Should Grant Rehearing, Reverse Revocation, and Restore Mpower’s full Eligibility to Serve Customers

Category: New York

On October 22, 2026 Mpower Energy filed a Request for Rehearing and Reconsideration asking the New York PSC to grant rehearing, reverse revocation, and restore Mpower’s full eligibility to serve existing customers.

As reported previously, on September 22, 2026 the NY PSC issued an Order Revoking Mpower Energy LLC’s Eligibility to Service Customers in New York State.

In its request for rehearing Mpower Energy argues the “September 2026 Order did not rest revocation on any single finding. It combined fourteen findings into a judgment that Mpower’s conduct reflected a “pervasive disregard” of the UBP and the Second Reset Order, and selected revocation on that basis.1 The record shows a different company. Mpower defended a contract-based legal position, sought the approvals its products required, disclosed its service relationships, answered Staff’s inquiries, revised its contracts during Staff’s review, and pursued the information it needed to respond. This Request challenges particular determinations and the account of Mpower’s conduct that turned them into a basis for market exclusion.

The home-warranty record illustrates the difference. Mpower petitioned for authority to offer its home-warranty product (“HWP”) in September 2020, obtained approval in the January 2021 Additional Products Order, and filed its HWP terms as that order directed. Answering Staff’s service questions, Mpower’s November 7, 2022 response named Dira Realty LLC (“Dira”) and told Staff that customers could obtain service “through Mpower’s affiliate.” When Staff asked for the service agreement in April 2023, Mpower filed it within a week. OTSC 2 nevertheless asserted that Mpower’s January 2025 letter claimed “apparently for the first time” that Dira was an affiliate. That record, further addressed in Sections III.D, III.G, and IV.E through IV.G, shows disclosure, not concealment.

Mpower also responded to each stage of Staff’s review. After Staff’s April 2023 request, it suspended HWP marketing and did not resume it. It filed revised HWP contracts four times between January 2023 and May 2024, and Staff’s November 2024 determination acknowledged that Mpower “has implemented Staff’s recommended corrections to its revised HWP contract filing from February 2024.” Staff’s grounds for declining approval included two subjects that its HWP White Paper had proposed to address by new rule, proposals on which the Commission has not acted, as further addressed in Sections III.G and IV.D. That is engagement with the regulator, not disregard of it.

The renewable and transition record follows the same pattern. Mpower’s continuing contract position, further addressed in Section IV.C, rests on its agreements, which treat monthly pricing separately from contractual duration and continue until terminated, and on the Commission’s statement that the Second Reset Order “only applies to prospective contracts.” Monthly pricing does not make those agreements expire and renew each month. The position challenges that classification, not the Commission’s authority to regulate the agreements, and Mpower maintained it to preserve customer relationships built over more than seventeen years. After Staff communicated its contrary view in mid-2022, Mpower obtained affirmative consent to move many thousands of renewable customers to its HWP. It purchased 148,000 national renewable energy credits (“RECs”) and retired them through PJM. Responding to Staff’s 2023 Notice of Apparent Violation, it offered VCPs for any 2021 shortfall on covered enrollments and renewals and committed to full-load REC purchases going forward. Its OTSC 1 response reported payment of VCPs for the 2022 compliance period. The Department’s own notices quantify the shortfalls by year, and NYSERDA confirmed to Staff in December 2025 that it had received a payment. Those are measurable compliance questions, as Section V.A explains, not evidence of indifference.

Mpower missed the OTSC 2 deadline because prior counsel’s email-security system captured the FOIL production messages that started the extended response period; Mpower did not know of the final production on February 6, 2026. After the Secretary denied Mpower’s request for more time on June 4, 2026, consistent with the advice Mpower received from prior counsel, it filed a complete response on July 10 and exhibits on July 16, more than two months before revocation. The September 2026 Order refused to consider them, entered Findings 5 through 9 by default, and treated the filing as further disregard on the premise that Mpower had been “explicitly instructed not to do so.” The June 4 Ruling denied additional time; it contains no express direction forbidding a filing, as further addressed in Sections IV.A and V.F. Mpower’s effort to place the OTSC 2 Response before the Commission thus became a further ground for revocation.

A separate records request presents a separate problem. On June 4, 2026, the Department received Mpower’s FOIL request for the records underlying the OTSC 3 customer account review. Mpower answered OTSC 3 while that request was pending and asked that OTSC 3 not be decided before it could address the records. The Department extended its own time to respond four times and produced the records on September 21, four days after the Commission’s session and one day before the September 2026 Order issued. The production included utility confirmations of changed account numbers, a Department notice bearing on receipt of materials relevant to Finding 12, and NYSERDA’s payment confirmation. Those records, further addressed in Sections III.J and VII, bear on Findings 2, 4, 10 through 12, and 14. Mpower had no opportunity to present them before the Commission acted.

The scope of the findings, further addressed in Section V.G, confirms the overstatement. Findings 1, 5, and 13 apply the same continuing-contract premise in three proceedings, while Findings 7 through 9 apply related reporting provisions to the same Dira relationship and disclosure history. Findings 10 through 14 concern identified accounts and records rather than companywide practices. Treating these overlapping theories and account-specific issues as independent episodes magnified their cumulative weight and supported a characterization of pervasive disregard that the underlying conduct does not establish. Mpower’s OTSC 3 response explained that thirteen of the eighteen accounts lacking a conventional agreement were its own internal accounts, and that the guaranteed-savings issue arose from one specially prepared agreement for a single customer and an internal reporting database field. Those findings do not establish pervasive disregard across a customer base the September 2026 Order itself puts at more than 29,000.

Even if the Commission sustains all fourteen findings, including those entered by default, revocation is unjust or unwarranted under PSL § 22, as further addressed in Section VI. On that assumption, Mpower’s conduct still matters because it shows which concerns can be addressed while service continues. Mpower’s OTSC 3 response proposed specific account-level corrections, including a written Internal Accounts Policy and modification of the GS reporting mechanism. Its OTSC 2 response stated that Mpower was prepared to amend the RAAF if the Commission concluded that an additional disclosure was required. The Commission’s Atlantic Energy and NRG orders, discussed in Section VI.C, show that enforceable corrective terms can protect customers while preserving eligibility, including, in NRG’s case, where the ESCOs maintained their denials.

Neither order dictates the result here. Revocation instead ends every New York customer relationship.

The Commission should grant rehearing, reverse revocation, and restore Mpower’s full eligibility to serve existing customers and to market to and enroll new customers on otherwise authorized products.”