News Stories

Got a tip or story? Share it with MAGNIFYI®.


DOER Files Step-by-Step Recommendation on Implementing Time Varying Rates

On November 5, 2026 comments were filed by the  Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources (DOER) regarding time-varying rates in Docket D.P.U. 26-62.

DOER requests that the Department adopt a timely, comprehensive approach to implementing default opt-out TOU rates that empower customers to reduce their electricity bills while delivering system-wide cost savings for all ratepayers.

Massachusetts ratepayers will benefit from time-of-use rates – DOER argues that “time-of-use (TOU) rates will likely produce bill savings for many customers immediately and empower customers to deepen bill savings by shifting energy usage to lower-cost periods, which in turn will produce short-and long-term system cost reductions that are shared by all ratepayers. Evidence from other jurisdictions demonstrates that a majority of customers enrolled on TOU rates can save money, oftentimes even before shifting load.”

Time-varying all three components of a customer’s bill will maximize benefits and promote cost causation – “a TOU rate is most cost-reflective when it incorporates every bill component for which underlying costs vary based on when electricity is consumed, which includes supply, transmission, and distribution. . . DOER’s proposed TOU rate would fully recover embedded distribution costs on a revenue-neutral basis while establishing higher on peak prices that reflect long-run marginal distribution costs, which have previously been identified in Massachusetts through marginal cost of service (MCOS) studies.”

Establishing reasonable guardrails for the opt-out process will reinforce rate design integrity – “DOER’s Petition supports default enrollment with a penalty-free option to opt out to an alternative rate at any time. However, at the technical conference, stakeholders raised the need to prevent customers from opting-out of a TOU rate to a flat rate before the summer season (during which the TOU rate may have a higher on-peak price) and then opt back into a TOU rate the following fall (during which the TOU rate may have a lower on-peak price).

“Other jurisdictions implementing default TOU rates tend to use one of three strategies to disincentivize that behavior: (1) requiring customers that opt-out of TOU and then re-enroll to remain on TOU for at least 12 months,20 (2) restricting customers from changing any rate election more than once in a 12-month period with exemptions for new rates or customers whose conditions have changed so as to warrant a rate change, 21, 22 or (3) disallowing customers that opt-out of TOU rates to return for at least 12 months.”

“DOER supports option (1) since the other two alternatives unnecessarily restrict a customer from enrollment.”

Implement default TOU rates via a two-phase approach beginning with supply and transmission, followed by distribution – “the Department should direct the EDCs to implement time-varied transmission and basic service rates simultaneously, effective April 1, 2028, followed by time-varied distribution rates at the conclusion of each EDC’s next base distribution rate case.”

“To implement transmission TOU rates, the Department should direct the EDCs to file time varied transmission rates at least two months before April 1, 2028. As confirmed by National Grid at the technical conference, the EDCs can adjust transmission rates at any point of the year via an interim filing. Therefore, the EDCs do not need to implement transmission TOU rates on the same timeline as the annual reconciliation filings, 29 which the EDCs typically file two months before annual transmission rates take effect (currently in January for Eversource and Unitil and March for National Grid).”

“To implement basic service TOU rates, the Department should direct the EDCs to file proposed tariff revisions as soon as practicable following a Department order to administratively set TOU supply rates by April 1, 2028. Under the basic service procurement schedule established in D.P.U. 23-50-A, the EDCs will issue requests for proposal for contracts that include 50% of basic service load for April 2028 in the first half of 2027, which does not allow sufficient time to update the basic service procurement process to explicitly procure time-varied products.”

Direct the EDCs to include at least one customer education tool sixty days before implementation of a default opt-out TOU rate on April 1, 2028 – “It is imperative to provide at least one customer education tool to customers at least 60 days before TVR implementation to reduce opt-out rates and increase customer comfort with TOU rates. 36 It is equally important that the EDCs implement TOU concurrently with AMI deployment and have enough time to engage customers in advance of implementation through Marketing, Education, and Outreach (MEO) efforts, which is why DOER’s proposed implementation timeline allows for approximately twelve months of MEO by the EDCs, assuming a Department decision on TVR by April 1, 2027.”

Direct the EDCs to coordinate with municipal aggregators and competitive suppliers – “DOER recognizes that over 70 percent of residential customers are enrolled on municipal aggregation or competitive supply rates, and therefore recommends the Department create a pathway to ensure that all customers have the option to benefit from time-varied supply rates. For customers on a TOU rate receiving supply from municipal aggregations or competitive suppliers, the price signal from TOU rates will be diluted if they remain on a flat supply rate, even if the TOU rate includes both distribution and transmission.”

“Competitive suppliers and municipal aggregations in Massachusetts have expressed interest in offering TOU supply rates, which requires resolving complex questions related to the provision of load settlement data and billing system modifications. To ensure that competitive suppliers and municipal aggregations are able to expeditiously offer TOU supply rates, DOER recommends that the Department resolve its pending load settlement investigation in D.P.U. 26- 44 prior to the EDCs submitting final MEO plans and direct the EDCs to coordinate with municipal aggregators and competitive suppliers in developing their MEO plans.”