News Stories

Got a tip or story? Share it with MAGNIFYI®.


Consumer Advocate Files Amended Complaint To Protect Customers From Negative Data Center Impacts

The Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate has filed an Amended Formal Complaint and Public Statement against PPL Electric at the Pennsylvania PUC concerning costs caused by computational large loads, in response to PPL Electric’s previously reported petition to make Network Integration Transmission Service (NITS) and certain other transmission costs nonbypassable.

The amended complaint is said to be necessary in order to -among other things- ensure protection of existing utility consumers from data center deployment.

“This Amended Complaint is necessary because the rapid onset of the massive amounts of electricity demand from planned and potential data centers onto PPL Electric’s utility electric systems is relatively new and impacting existing Pennsylvania utility consumers today and will continue to impact these consumers into the future. Fortunately, a “Public Policy Consensus” that is positive for existing utility consumers has emerged, with some level of buy-in from the data center industry. That Public Policy Consensus directs public utilities to ensure that: (1) data centers pay for the costs that they cause related to the addition of new utility infrastructure to both interconnect data centers and meet the data centers’ electricity demand needs; (2) data centers bear the risks of stranded costs related to new utility infrastructure that is built to interconnect data centers and meet data center demand; and (3) data centers bear the risks and consequences related to any reliability impacts caused by their additions to utility systems operated by EDCs and the regional grid operated by PJM. While the Public Policy Consensus aspires to protect existing consumers from the costs, risks, and reliability impacts of interconnecting data centers to utility systems, the work now for this Complainant, Respondent, Commission, and other interested parties, is to ensure that the goal of protecting existing ratepayers is effectuated through binding utility tariffs governing rates, rules, and regulations of utility service and other binding requirements relating to certain aspects of utility service.”

The Consumer Advocate expands upon its position regarding data center additions to electricity systems – “The interconnection of large-scale data centers to electric utility systems in Pennsylvania presents opportunities and challenges. As opportunities, if introduced and implemented in a thoughtful and considered manner that places reliability and affordability at the forefront, utility consumers can potentially benefit from the addition of data centers to electricity systems. As challenges, without sufficient safeguards for utility ratepayers, the interconnection of new data centers could create substantial upward pressure on electricity bills and increase electricity reliability risks for existing consumers. Such an outcome would be untenable because Pennsylvania ratepayers (1) did not cause or contribute to the drivers of these increased costs and reliability risks; and (2) already are experiencing increased electricity rates and affordability challenges, due to many factors, as well as decreased service reliability due to increased outages due to storms.

To protect existing consumers from escalating costs of electricity bills that for some is increasingly unaffordable, data centers should pay for the costs they are causing to serve their electricity needs. Data centers should pay for network upgrade infrastructure costs, both transmission and distribution, that are incurred by utility providers to meet their needs given that data centers are the but-for causers of and receive commensurate benefit from the new infrastructure. Additionally, data centers should pay their fair share of embedded costs of electricity systems. Additionally, to mitigate price increases for existing consumers, data centers should pay for the increased PJM capacity, RBP, and IRAS costs that are incurred by providers in the PJM markets to serve their needs.”