Feature Articles
Have a topic request or want to submit an article? Contact the MAGNIFYI Editors
Supply Agendas in Flux for Commercial and Industrial Customers
Commercial and industrial energy purchasers have an agenda beyond the lowest possible price, retail energy executives said at a conference late last month, but providers have to dig deep to discover the other motives.
Key Takeaways: Commercial & Industrial Energy Procurement
Speakers at the EMC 26 conference in Washington, D.C., last month said that the route to affordable long-term prices may not be a straight line, and diverse energy sources are being considered as these customers attempt to manage their power load.
“There is uncertainty in a lot of commercial and industrial,” said Charles de Casteja, managing partner of Good Energy, a procurement consultant, broker, and community energy aggregator. “People want the longest fixed price that they can. We have come full circle.”
Customers want risk allocation as well as a fixed price, said Misti Day, vice president of operations at Spark Energy, and at the end of the day, they want cheap power and gas.
Larger electricity clients typically want an index price or index plus, or index plus pass-through, she said. The last structure relies on a wholesale index, fixed supplier adder and a pass-through of charges like capacity, transmission, line losses, ancillary services or renewable compliance costs.
Blend-and-extend type products are no longer the automatic choice, said Alexandra Williams, vice president of origination at Guidepost Energy, an energy management advisor.
Blend-and-extend refers to a contract restructuring of energy supply with a new, longer-term deal before the original expiration date and at a lower price.
Companies with loads of 50 MW or more want to lock in long-term deals and also will pay a premium for other forms of risk management, Williams said.
“There is a premium willing to be paid for fixing capacity or long-term regulatory risk or locking into political risk,” she added. “ERCOT (Electric Reliability Council of Texas) is now a political market, where we were not a few years ago.”
Bart Fromuth, CEO of Freedom Energy Logistics, said data center capacity costs show up in every conversation in New England.
“There is more demand and no [more] material supply,” he said. “There is backwardation in the market and customers are taking advantage.”
“We are trying to get all the new capacity we can in New England in 2028,” said de Casteja.
In ISO New England, every user’s electricity supply cost includes a charge for capacity based on a capacity tag. The tag is based on its load during the grid’s peak hour of the year, and becomes effective the following year beginning June 1 for a 12-month period.
Energy sourcing also under review
Retail energy providers have for too long been in competition to supply energy, which is a small, easy part of customer needs, said Gabe Phillips, CEO of Catalyst Power.
“The system is not set up to value a flexible, cleaner kilowatt hour,” he said. “The product is treated as interchangeable, so that price is the only way to compete.”
In most consuming markets, transmission and distribution charges can be 75% of the bill in some cases for commercial and industrial customers, Phillips said, while the industry fights over the other 25%.
“The system is built to reward fast and cheap,” he continued. “Many competitors and colleagues address total customer exposure, but it is still not enough.
“Stop selling a rate, so we can manage the customer’s whole energy system. The opportunity is not to sell more energy. It is to create more value for each kilowatt hour the customer uses.”
“Sustainability, reliability and affordability are all still on the table,” said Richard Spillky, principal in retail market development at Constellation Energy. “Customers are thinking much more deeply on how to combine the three. We are having the most in-depth conversations in a long time.”
Data centers in Texas still seek sustainability and the fastest MW to acquire, Williams said, and customers are not as agnostic to price or to the source as many believe.
Control of energy expenses
The federal phaseout of tax credits for renewable energy is shifting customer focus from generation to storage and load management, said Jeffrey Prutsman, CEO of Facility Innovations Group, an energy solutions provider.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 gave wind and solar projects much shorter windows to either be placed in service or to start construction and take advantage of the investment tax credit or the production tax credit.
“There is a shift from generation to peak load management based on prices between 4 p.m. and 7 p.m. in the summer,” he said.
Offsetting summer load in the PJM Interconnection can be 70% of the savings that can be achieved on any kind of load management plan, Prutsman added.
“There needs to be better market incentives to not consume in regulated markets, and to curtail capacity costs,” Williams said. “Connecting to the grid faster and incentivizing generation through ancillary services and other means has to be a critical solution. It is crazy that we are not talking about that more.”
Editor’s Picks

